9 Tips to Make Your Property Appeal to Better Tenants

Renting out your property isn’t just about securing tenants; it’s about finding tenants who are responsible, reliable, and capable of paying good rent on time. The right tenants will treat your property with respect and care, making the landlord-tenant relationship smoother and more rewarding. We’re going to highlight the nine top ways to make your property appeal to better tenants. These are the big ones!

Photo of a home with a house for rent sign in front - 9 Tips to Make Your Property Appeal to Better Tenants
If you really want to make your property appeal to better tenants, it’s going to take some work. | Photo by Ivan Samkov

9 Tips to Make Your Property Appeal to Better Tenants

Signing top tenants is huge. However, attracting such tenants requires more than a simple listing or just refreshing the paint. It calls for strategic investments and thoughtful upgrades that make your property stand out. From enhancing the curb appeal to modernizing key spaces, these tips will help you turn your rental into a magnet for quality tenants.

1. Transform Your Bathroom for a Modern Look

Bathrooms hold a unique power to sway a tenant’s decision. An outdated or poorly maintained bathroom can be a dealbreaker, while a modern, stylish one can be a standout feature. Fortunately, transforming a bathroom doesn’t always require a full renovation.

Upgrade the fixtures first. Replace leaky faucets, dated showerheads, and old toilets with water-efficient models. A rain showerhead or a sleek, modern sink can make a big impact without hurting your wallet. Lighting also plays a huge role—bright, well-placed lights can make the space feel larger and more inviting.

If your budget allows, consider professional bathroom remodeling for more extensive changes, like re-tiling the shower or replacing the flooring. Small details, such as fresh caulking around the tub, a new mirror, or updated cabinet hardware, can refresh the bathroom without requiring a major overhaul. Tenants appreciate a bathroom that is clean, functional, and visually appealing.

2. Upgrade the Kitchen with Tenant-Friendly Features

First on the list for many renters is the kitchen—a dealmaker or breaker. These days, tenants look for a kitchen that’s modern, functional, and aesthetically pleasing. So, what changes can you make? If you really want to make your property appeal to better tenants begin with the kitchen. Ensure all appliances are in good working order and replace outdated ones if necessary. Energy-efficient models are especially attractive as they help tenants save on utility bills.

Countertops and cabinetry are also key focus areas. While granite countertops or custom cabinetry may not be feasible for every landlord, affordable upgrades like laminate countertops or painted cabinets can still deliver a fresh, updated look. 

Functionality matters, too. Ensure there’s adequate counter space and storage. Even small additions, such as under-cabinet lighting or an extra set of shelves, can make the kitchen more appealing to tenants who value convenience and practicality.

3. Improve Curb Appeal

Take a look at your property’s exterior and think like a tenant – does it attract you? If not, it’s time for some changes. A well-maintained exterior suggests that you’re a responsible landlord who cares about the property.

The first step should be to tidy up the landscaping. Mow the lawn, trim any overgrown bushes, and plant flowers or shrubs to add a touch of color. Power wash the driveway and sidewalks for a cleaner, fresher appearance. Repainting the front door in an inviting color can also create a warm welcome.

Outdoor lighting is another key consideration. Not only does it enhance the property’s aesthetics, but it also improves safety—a major concern for many tenants, especially seniors or people with kids

4. Prioritize Cleanliness and Maintenance

Having a clean and safe space is essential in order to make your property appeal to better tenants, No amount of upgrades will matter if your property isn’t clean and well-maintained. A deep clean before showing the property is non-negotiable. Tenants will notice—and appreciate—a spotless environment.

Regular maintenance checks are just as important. Ensure plumbing, heating, and electrical systems are in excellent condition. Address any minor repairs, such as squeaky doors or leaky faucets, before showing the property. These proactive efforts signal to tenants that you’re attentive and responsible, which encourages them to treat the property with respect.

5. Add Modern Technology and Smart Features

In today’s tech-savvy world, smart home features can give your property an edge. Tenants value convenience, and small investments in technology can make your rental more appealing.

Consider installing a smart thermostat to help tenants save on energy bills. Keyless entry systems add both security and ease of access. If your property has outdoor spaces, security cameras or video doorbells can increase the sense of safety.

These features position your property as modern and encourage potential tenants to make good offers. Tenants are often willing to pay a premium for added convenience and security.

6. Refresh the Interior with Neutral Colors

While refreshing the paint isn’t all you should do to improve your property’s look, it’s not wise to skip this upgrade either. After all, it is one of the simplest and most affordable ways to revitalize your property. However, the color palette you choose matters. Neutral shades like white, beige, and light gray appeal to a broad range of tenants because they create a clean, versatile backdrop that complements any decor style.

Neutral colors also make rooms appear brighter and more spacious, enhancing the overall perception of the property. Avoid bold or overly personal colors that could alienate some potential renters. Regularly repainting walls, particularly in high-traffic areas, keeps your property looking fresh and well-maintained, which leaves a positive impression on prospective tenants.

7. Highlight Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is increasingly important to tenants who are looking to save on utility bills and reduce their environmental footprint. Properties that offer energy-efficient home upgrades are often more attractive and can even command higher rent.

Consider upgrading windows to double-pane or energy-efficient models if your budget allows. These help with insulation and reduce heating and cooling costs. Installing LED lighting throughout the property is a low-cost way to improve energy efficiency while providing brighter, longer-lasting illumination.

For landlords willing to make a larger investment, adding insulation to walls and ceilings or upgrading to an energy-efficient HVAC system can pay off in the long term.

Pro Tip: Once you take the time and money to make your property appeal to better tenants, it will only happen if you communicate these benefits to potential renters. Don’t forget to mention these features in your property listing, as they’re often a deciding factor for eco-conscious tenants. This is key!

9. Be Transparent and Professional

While property upgrades play a critical role, your behavior as a landlord is just as important. Professionalism and transparency can make a strong impression on prospective tenants and set the tone for a positive landlord-tenant relationship.

Be upfront about lease terms, rent prices, and any additional costs, such as utilities or maintenance fees. Clearly outline what’s included in the rent, whether it’s access to parking, appliances, or communal spaces. This clarity builds trust and attracts tenants who value honest communication.

Respond promptly to inquiries and show a willingness to address any concerns during property viewings. A well-prepared and professional approach signals to tenants that you’re reliable and invested in their experience, which appeals to high-quality renters looking for a hassle-free rental arrangement.

If you can somehow complete all nine of these tips you will most certainly make your property appeal to better tenants. These strategies not only appeal to responsible tenants but also foster long-term relationships, reducing turnover and ensuring your investment is well cared for. With thoughtful planning and attention to detail, you can turn your property into a welcoming home for the kind of tenants every landlord needs.

Tre Pryor, Realtor

Tre Pryor is the leading real estate expert in the city of Louisville. He is a multi-million dollar producer and consistently ranks in the top 1% of Louisville Realtors for homes sold. Tre Pryor has the highest possible rating—5.0 stars on Google—by his clients and is routinely interviewed by the local NBC news. Tre Pryor is a member of the RE/MAX Hall of Fame.